Rethinking bridge resilience in a changing climate
At a glance
Climate change is forcing a rethink of how bridge resilience is assessed, funded and delivered across New Zealand. Drawing on project experience and research, this article challenges traditional assumptions about bridge replacement and explores opportunities to balance risk, resilience and affordability more effectively.
In recent years, Aotearoa New Zealand has experienced severe weather events that have tested the resilience of our transport networks. The Auckland Anniversary floods and Cyclone Gabrielle exposed vulnerabilities across roads, bridges and supporting infrastructure, causing hundreds of millions of dollars in damage. Insurance claims following recent severe weather events have also highlighted the growing financial consequences of flood-related infrastructure damage and disruption.
These events have prompted a closer look at how we plan, design and invest in transport assets. Recent revisions to flood modelling have reinforced that challenge, with events once considered exceptionally rare now assessed as increasingly likely.
This changes how infrastructure owners approach the replacement of ageing assets. The balance between what is affordable and what is resilient in a changing climate must therefore be carefully considered.
The next wave of bridge replacements
Across New Zealand, many bridge owners are preparing for a wave of renewal and replacement decisions. Traditionally, those decisions have been driven by condition assessments, maintenance requirements and structural performance. Climate resilience now sits alongside these considerations.
As rainfall intensity increases and flood models evolve, so does our understanding of network risk due to flooding. Earth Sciences New Zealand estimates that around 26,800 kilometres of road are currently exposed to flooding, with that figure expected to grow as climate impacts become more pronounced. Many ageing bridges now sit within newly identified flood-prone areas, including structures located in some of the country's most remote regions.
That creates a difficult reality: Aotearoa is unlikely to have the financial capacity to replace every bridge vulnerable to future flooding while also upgrading each structure to the highest resilience standards available today. We need a smarter approach that secures priority routes and makes better use of the available bridge replacement budget.
A new way of thinking
For decades, the preferred response to increasing flood risk has been straightforward: raise the bridge design level as predicted flood levels increase. Higher bridges reduce exposure to inundation and avoid many flood-related loading challenges. The challenge is that, as design flood levels continue to rise, so too do the cost and complexity of achieving that outcome.
Higher bridge levels often require longer bridge structures, more extensive approach embankments, increased scour protection and potentially substantial changes to road approaches over considerable distances. These works may be impractical or exacerbate flooding elsewhere. Additional earthworks and land acquisition can quickly dominate project costs and, in many rural locations, can be difficult to justify.
As revised floodplains expand both vertically and horizontally, more bridges are exposed to flood risk. This raises the question of whether every bridge needs to remain above floodwaters during extreme events, or whether some could instead be designed to safely withstand periods of inundation while maintaining their structural integrity.
Reducing reliance on climate predictions
An alternative approach came into focus on several bridge replacement projects in Auckland and Gisborne, where new structures were required to replace approximately 70-year-old bridges that had been washed away by floods.
Rather than substantially raising the replacement structures, our design team considered options that retained the existing bridge and road alignments and allowed the bridges to be safely overtopped under revised, climate-adjusted flood estimates.
The trade-off is that the crossings would be temporarily unavailable at the peak of a major flood, and their edge barriers might require replacement, particularly where debris is present in the flow. However, retaining the existing alignments enables shorter bridge structures, avoids extensive approach embankments that could alter river flows, and provides a practical and cost-effective solution.
It also offers resilience beyond the design event: once a bridge is fully submerged, the forces acting on it increase only incrementally as flood depth rises, allowing a structure designed for submergence to withstand floods substantially deeper than the design flood.
Interpreting flood loading standards in New Zealand
While retaining bridges on existing alignments can deliver lower costs and improved resilience, the current treatment of flood loading can create varying outcomes depending on designers’ assumptions and interpretations. This variability can materially affect project costs, with implications for how far limited network investment budgets can stretch.
At face value, designing for inundation appears relatively straightforward, with existing standards providing a framework for assessing flood loading on submerged bridges. It is only when working through their detailed application that ambiguities and potential conservatism become apparent. Much of the current guidance stems from research undertaken in Queensland during the late 1990s, and while that work remains highly valuable, several areas within current provisions are open to interpretation, leading different designers to adopt different approaches.
Design outcomes can be heavily influenced by early assumptions, including where the approach velocity is taken from a hydraulic model and what factors are applied to it. Other considerations such as debris loading, concurrent loading scenarios and barrier system design can also have a substantial impact on the final solution and project cost. We shared these findings at the NZ Bridge and Geotechnical Conference in 2026, focusing on the opportunities for a more consistent and risk-based approach.
This presents an opportunity to refine the design rules for submerged bridges so they provide greater consistency, avoid unnecessary conservatism and reduce the need for departures from the NZTA Bridge Manual or clarifications of its provisions.
Doing more with less
As New Zealand adapts to a changing climate, resilience should be viewed less as eliminating all risk and more as understanding and managing it effectively.
Not every vulnerability in the transport network can be removed. Instead, investment should be directed to where it delivers the greatest network benefit, while alternative approaches are considered where they provide a better balance of resilience, cost and acceptable risk.
Bridge owners face ageing assets, changing climate projections and increasingly constrained budgets. Balancing resilience, cost and acceptable risk is therefore becoming central to their investment decisions.
The future of bridge design will not always involve building higher. In suitable locations, shorter and more cost-effective replacement bridges can instead be designed to withstand inundation. This approach would allow more bridges to be renewed within available capital budgets, improving resilience across the wider network rather than concentrating investment in a smaller number of highly elevated structures.